|
The Honorable Mike Doyle
Op-Ed: We Can't Rebuild Iraq Alone
The Price of a Failed Foreign Policy is $166 Billion and Counting
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
October 20, 2003
Congress is currently considering President Bush’s request for
$87 billion for the ongoing war in Iraq. Last week, the House and Senate
each approved legislation to cover the cost of occupying and rebuilding
Iraq in 2004, but the bills contained a number of significant differences.
Congress is currently working to draft a version of this legislation that
both bodies can agree to.
President Bush wants to pass the burden of paying for the occupation
and reconstruction of Iraq –estimated at between $238 billion and
$418 billion – on to our children in the form of a larger national
debt. The larger budget deficits that this increased borrowing would produce
would also make it much more difficult to enact a Medicare prescription
drug benefit, fix our outdated electric utility network, and invest in
our children’s education.
A lot of Americans, myself included, are asking why we are being asked
to forego rebuilding America in order to rebuild Iraq – and why
we aren’t getting help from our “Coalition of the Willing”
allies in paying for it?
Let me make one thing clear. I’m not suggesting that we cut and
run. We need to support our troops, and we have to win the peace in Iraq.
Nevertheless, I couldn’t support the President’s request as
currently structured.
When you compare the coalition that President Bush’s father put
together with his son’s “Coalition of the Willing,”
an obvious question arises. Why did the first Persian Gulf War cost our
country only $10 billion while the recent war has a price tag –
so far – of $166 billion?
The obvious answer is that the first President Bush put together a real
coalition that supported our policies and contributed most of the money
needed to pay for that war. The “Coalition of the Willing”
assembled by the current President Bush, in striking contrast, is a paper
tiger. Practically no other country has provided any significant support
for this effort. And yet, we clearly need foreign troops and financial
support if we are to be successful in creating a stable democratic Iraq.
I opposed the war resolution last year because in the absence of an imminent
threat to our country, I believed that the United States should have pursued
a multilateral approach to deal with our concerns about weapons of mass
destruction by giving inspections more time and building a bigger international
coalition. It’s clear now that Iraq posed no imminent threat to
our country and that we could have safely pursued this approach –
which would have saved hundreds of American lives and billions of dollars.
Instead, President Bush’s approach alienated many potential allies
and made them unwilling to help us rebuild Iraq. Now Americans are paying
the price.
President Bush also did a poor job of putting together his plan for rebuilding
Iraq. The Bush Administration has proposed spending the American taxpayers’
hard-earned money on some of the most outrageous “reconstruction”
projects one could imagine – creating a zip code system for Iraq,
building luxury prisons, subsidizing MBA classes, building public housing
and restoring Iraqi marshlands (things he would never support in our country),
and funding a witness protection program.
Expecting Congress to approve such a request is an insult to every American.
We have to support our troops, but tying reconstruction money in with
the money for our troops without the necessary accountability would be
a disservice to the entire nation and a dereliction of Congress’s
responsibility. Moreover, we should provide our reconstruction assistance
to Iraq in the form of loans and loan guarantees.
The United States must do a better job of getting the international community
involved in rebuilding Iraq. That means giving the United Nations a bigger
role in rebuilding Iraq – which is desirable in any case. President
Bush got us into an unnecessary and expensive war, alienated most of our
potential allies, and failed to develop a viable exit strategy for our
troops. I believe that the United States must now bring other countries
into the reconstruction process and make certain that our reconstruction
aid is spent wisely.
Finally, to the extent that U.S. taxpayers must foot a share of the bill,
we should pay for it by postponing or repealing the President’s
recent tax cuts for the wealthiest Americans. I feel strongly that the
best long-term interests of the United States are not served by passing
the cost of paying for this war on to our children.
|