Is There an Antidote to the Republican Amnesia?
The Huffington Post
March 18, 2009
Memory eventually fails us all, but apparently the decline strikes one party
far more than the other.
In recent weeks, my friends across the aisle have expended a lot of breath
proclaiming that the Democrats caused the present financial crisis by failing
to pass legislation to regulate financial services companies in the years
1995 through 2006.
There is only small one problem with this story -- throughout this entire
period the Republicans were in complete charge of the House and for the
most critical years they controlled the House, the Senate, and the Presidency.
In the House of Representatives, the majority party has almost unlimited
power over the minority party. The majority party owns the committee chairmanships;
it controls what bills come to a vote; and it is under no obligation to
consider the ideas of the beleaguered minority. When the Republicans were
in the majority they ruled with an iron first; it is no accident that Tom
DeLay was known as "The Hammer."
That is why I find it particularly flattering the Republicans now claim
that in the years 1995 to 2006 I personally possessed supernatural powers
which enabled me to force mighty Republican leaders to do my bidding. Choose
your comic book hero -- I was all of them.
I wish I had the power to force the Republican leadership to do my bidding!
If I had had that power, I would have used it to block the impeachment of
Bill Clinton, to stop the war in Iraq, to prevent large tax cuts for the
extremely wealthy, and to stop government intervention into the private
life of Terri Schiavo. Yet that power eluded me, and I was unable to stop
those things.
According to the Republicans' misty memories of the period before 2007,
I allegedly singlehandedly blocked their determined efforts to regulate
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, and my supposed intransigence literally caused
the worldwide financial crisis.
Fortunately, we have tools to aid memory -- pencil and paper, word processing,
transcripts, newspapers, and the Congressional record. And as described
in the most reputable published sources, in 2005 I in fact worked together
with my Republican colleague Michael Oxley, then Chairman of the Financial
Services Committee, to write a bill to increase regulation of Fannie Mae
and Freddie Mac. We passed the bill out of committee with an overwhelming
majority -- every Democrat voted in favor of the legislation. However, on
the House floor the Republican leadership added a poison pill amendment,
which would have prevented non-profit institutions with religious affiliations
from receiving funds. I voted against the legislation in protest, though
I continued to work with Mr. Oxley to encourage the Senate to pass a good
bill. But these efforts were defeated because President Bush blocked further
consideration of the legislation. In the words of Mr. Oxley, no flaming
liberal, the Bush administration gave his efforts 'the one-finger salute.'
The Republicans can claim some supposed successes despite my awesome power.
In 1999 they passed the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, which overturned a Depression-era
law preventing commercial banks from acting like investment banks. In 2000,
they passed another bill which loosened regulation of derivative markets.
I voted against these bills -- but to no avail.
Under Republican President George W. Bush, many federal agencies turned
a blind eye to activities which would later precipitate the global financial
meltdown. The Securities and Exchange Commission decided to allow the nation's
largest financial institutions to "self-regulate;" the Federal Reserve under
Alan Greenspan declined to use its power to regulate subprime mortgages;
the Comptroller of the Currency decided to preempt state consumer laws on
subprime mortgages.
Meanwhile, President Bush himself demanded that Fannie and Freddie increase
the percentage of subprime loans they purchased, supposedly because of his
belief in an "ownership society." Incidentally, increased lending to subprime
borrowers would also fuel astronomical profits by the financial services
industry. I publicly opposed giving mortgages to unqualified borrowers because
I believed that some families are better off renting.
Yet somehow none of this was recorded in the Republican collective memory.
Forgotten too is the significant progress that was made after the 2006 elections,
when the Republicans in Congress were repudiated by American voters.
Ironically, this is the period in which I and my Democratic colleagues actually
did possess the magical power needed to make real change in Washington --
we became the majority party. In March 2007, just two months after I became
the Chairman of the Financial Services Committee for the first time, I moved
quickly to forge a bill which would regulate Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
The bill passed the House in May, with all 223 Democrats voting for it,
and 103 Republicans voting against it. President Bush later signed that
legislation into law.
Later in 2007, I introduced legislation to restrict subprime mortgages.
The bill passed the Financial Services Committee and the House, but it did
not pass the Senate, where because of the filibuster rule, the Republican
minority actually does have the power to hobble the majority. The bill passed
the full House with all 227 Democrats and 64 Republicans voting for it,
and 127 Republicans voting against.
Ironically, those Republicans who now attack me most viciously and whose
memories are the most impaired were among those who voted against both bills.
Republicans also forget -- or do not understand -- that the present financial
crisis has many fathers. The failure to pass any meaningful legislation
before 2007 allowed unscrupulous actors to gorge themselves at the public's
expense. Unregulated mortgage brokers sold subprime loans including the
now infamous NINA (No Income No Assets). Major financial institutions packaged
bad mortgages into securities and sold them as low-risk investments. Rating
agencies gave stellar grades to toxic assets while being paid by the companies
who stood to benefit from their actions. Insurance companies like AIG issued
Credit Default Swaps which magically turned toxic assets into gold.
The executives of some of those institutions now seek bonuses for their
fine work. Perhaps my Republican colleagues should ask for bonuses too.
The true tragedy is that this is more than a game. Millions of Americans
are now unemployed and millions of others have lost their homes. Well-run
businesses have been shaken to their foundations, and the stock market has
taken a plunge not seen since the Great Depression. Many people facing retirement
have found their savings have been cut in half.
They say that those who forget history are doomed to repeat it. But the
collective amnesia of the Republican Party will not only hurt its members
-- it threatens to hurt all of us. Is there a cure for amnesia? We can only
hope.