| Lungren In the News | |||
![]() | |||
| It's time to stop 'birth citizenship' | |||
|
By Lamar Smith and Dan Lungren | |||
|
December 9, 2005 | |||
| WASHINGTON - In what way is Nearly every industrialized country in the world requires at least one parent to be a citizen or legal immigrant before a child born there becomes a citizen. Not a single country in Why is birth citizenship a concern? The most recent data indicate that nearly 20 percent of all births in Once an illegal immigrant gives birth in the This granting of automatic citizenship comes from a misinterpretation of the 14th Amendment. It was drafted after the Civil War to guarantee that the recently freed slaves gained full citizenship rights. When it was enacted in 1868, there were no illegal immigrants in the Professor Peter Schuck of Legal experts disagree as to whether a constitutional amendment or a federal statute is needed to eliminate "birth citizenship." However, there are three reasons why Congress can and should act: (1) No Supreme Court case has dealt directly with the offspring of illegal immigrants and the question of automatic citizenship. (2) The Constitution expressly gives Congress the power to decide national immigration policies. (3) During the debate on the 14th Amendment in 1866, the senator who was the author said it would "not of course include persons born in the Congress is long overdue in making sure the 14th Amendment is correctly interpreted. Illegal immigration has become a crisis in Passing a law to eliminate birth citizenship would help deter illegal immigration and reduce the burden on the taxpayer of paying for illegal immigrants' education, health care and other government benefits.
Lungren, a Republican from |
|||
|
In the News List | ![]() |