Commentary from
Congressman Joe Pitts
Sixteenth District of Pennsylvania

504 Cannon House Office Building  ·  Washington, DC  20515 
Contact: Gabe Neville (202) 225-2411 ·  FAX: (202) 225-2013  ·  Internet: www.house.gov/pitts


For Immediate Release
July 13, 2000

Teddy Roosevelt’s Charge for Freedom
By Congressman Joseph R. Pitts

“Then I am the ranking officer here and I give the order to charge!” said Colonel Teddy Roosevelt on a cloudless and hot July morning at the base of a now-famous hill outside Santiago, Cuba.  The Battle of San Juan Hill had begun, but the Rough Riders had not yet been given the order to advance.  Kettle Hill lay in front of them, and the jungle behind.  Spanish soldiers fired away from the haciendas atop the hill, sending “sheets of lead” down on Roosevelt’s men.

The future president had had enough.  The only way to take the hill was to charge, and he gave the order.  Colonel Roosevelt mounted his horse—it was easier to command from horseback, though it made him an easier target.  Since their horses had been left behind in Florida, his men charged on foot.  The Rough Riders had already suffered nearly half their casualties of the day.

The First and Ninth regiments of regulars—positioned next to the Rough Riders—were reluctant to follow Roosevelt’s command.  A captain of the Ninth protested, saying his orders were to keep his men lying where they were and to await the order to advance. “Then let my men through, sir,” was Roosevelt’s reply.

Up the hill they went, followed very soon by the Ninth and parts of the First regiments.  Braving a hail of bullets, and suffering many casualties, they took the hill.  Contrary to the common misunderstanding, it was this charge up Kettle Hill that propelled Roosevelt to fame.  The Rough Riders, recruited by Roosevelt, was a diverse band of volunteers made up of rich Eastern college boys, cowboys from the West, Indians from Oklahoma, and Mexican-Americans from New Mexico. The Ninth Cavalry, which fought alongside the Rough Riders, was a black regiment (led by white officers).

The Battle of San Juan Hill forced the hand of the Spanish, whose last hope was their fleet harbored at Santiago. The American Navy was blockading it, and the Army advance out of the hills forced the Spanish to mount a futile breakout attempt.  The war was all but over.

The Spanish American War was fought to free Cuba from the abuses of Spanish rule.  Though America gained possession of Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Philippines, the war was fought in defense of freedom.  Cuba, which was immediately made independent, is the only one of the four territories that is not today governed democratically.

Three American generals recommended Roosevelt for the Medal of Honor—America’s highest military award—for his conspicuous bravery at the Battle of San Juan Hill.  An odd political offense, however, prevented it.  Large numbers of American soldiers contracted typhoid and yellow fever during the war, many of them dying.  Roosevelt and many other officers believed the American troops should be withdrawn immediately, but the War Department—today’s Department of Defense—left them in Cuba until 1902 in part because they feared they would import an epidemic to the mainland.  Roosevelt took the lead in protesting this decision, and it cost him the medal.

His wife reported that he regretted the loss of the medal to the day he died.  Roosevelt won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1906 for negotiating an end to the Russo-Japanese War, but apparently found that to be small consolation.

Rep. Rick Lazio of New York has led a congressional effort to award the Medal of Honor to Teddy Roosevelt posthumously.  Roosevelt’s bravery at the battle was clear to everyone who served with him and has become legendary.  The Rough Riders suffered the highest casualty rate of the war, 20 percent, and Roosevelt himself was wounded by shrapnel during the battle.

Congress passed legislation two years ago authorizing the award, and the President signed it.  Roosevelt’s great-grandson Tweed Roosevelt has lobbied hard in Washington, and the Secretary of the Army and the Secretary of Defense have both recommended that the award be made.  The formal recommendation to present the posthumous award has been sitting for months, now, on the President’s desk awaiting his signature.  President Clinton should waste no more time and make the award. He should give his predecessor the honor he is due.

Rep. Pitts is currently guest-curating an exhibit of presentation albums of American stamp proofs at the National Postal Museum in Washington.  The rare albums were compiled during President Roosevelt’s administration as gifts to his friends.  More information is available at http://www.si.edu/postal.  Additional information on the campaign to posthumously award President Roosevelt the Medal of Honor is available at http://www.house.gov/lazio.

#   #   #

Welcome ·  About Joe Pitts ·  The District ·  Key Initiatives ·  Legislation ·  Constituent Services
Press & Speeches
·  The Federal Government ·  Links ·  Contact Information · 
Home