|
When Congress takes up the children’s health insurance bill
this week, the debate will reflect the much broader discussion of
health care reform in general. This larger issue certainly
deserves the attention it’s getting: Health care consumes about
one-seventh of our economy and is vitally important to
Americans’ standard of living.
The most frequently cited challenges in health care are, of
course, cost and coverage: Health care costs are rising too fast,
and nearly 50 million people have no health insurance at all.
Unfortunately, many of the proposed reforms try to address these
legitimate concerns in an incremental and piecemeal fashion. Many
reforms also contain — or lead in the direction of — a
standard mix of impersonal regulations, mandates and centralized
control that will only add more layers of burdensome complexity.
What’s needed is a fresh vision — a 21st-century approach that
transforms health care itself in a way that builds on our
nation’s most fundamental strengths. Here are some of the
criteria that should apply:
· Reform must be comprehensive. Health care is not a separate and
discrete part of our economy. It is a dynamic network of
participants in both the private and public sectors, who are
constantly interacting and readjusting to one another. Further
complicating this arrangement are the federal tax code, the
government’s large and costly health programs — Medicare and
Medicaid — and the lack of transparency in the cost of medical
services, to name just a few. Because the components of health
care range so widely, addressing the problems in only one or two
areas while leaving the others unchanged will yield only limited
and temporary benefits. We must look to the broad landscape to
ensure that health care reform will be truly beneficial and
lasting.
· It should be built on the principle of individual ownership.
Comprehensiveness, however, does not necessarily require greater
complexity. In fact, the most profound benefits are likely to come
from the broad application of well-known, long-standing
principles.
One of these is ownership. Individual ownership has long been a
central component of America’s prosperity. Yet this principle
still does not apply in health care, one of our most valued
resources. One reason is the federal tax code, which creates a
bias in favor of third-party payers of health insurance and
against individual purchasers. As a result, health insurance is
owned by employers or the government, and this means patients
don’t really control their own health care choices. Health
insurance should be owned by the individuals who use it. This
would restore the most important relationship in health care —
between the patient and the doctor — and would also encourage
insurers to develop a greater variety of coverage options, making
the health insurance market itself more effective and more
efficient.
· It must provide health care security. Clearly, any reform plan
must provide a sustainable safety net for low-income people or
those with health problems that put affordable coverage out of
their reach. A number of state governments have established
“high-risk” insurance pools for such individuals — proving
once again that state governments often are more responsive to
their specific populations. We should encourage more of this
state-based creativity, and at the same time arm individuals with
the resources to buy across state lines if necessary.
· It must promote our international competitiveness. These things
must be achieved without vastly expanding government spending and
taxes. These burdens are the greatest threat to our nation’s
ability to compete and lead in the international economy; a
failure of economic competitiveness will jeopardize our ability to
provide ever-improving health care services and make them
available to everyone. This is another reason why reform in the
health care market must be with reforms of government health
programs.
The problems in health care are complex and demanding — but they
are not impossible. What’s needed is a comprehensive,
forward-looking approach that builds on our creativity, our
economic strengths and our compassion. Above all, it should
transform health care to respond to the most important contributor
toward America’s prosperity: the individual American.
Rep. Paul Ryan (Wis.) is the ranking Republican on the House
Budget Committee.
|